Carillo, played well today. Drew the first PP that the team scored on took the body all day and was disciplined while agitating the other team all day.

That is exactly what he is here to do.
The line he was on hemmed the Stall, line in the their end on a few occasions for their whole shift! Did you not see that or you can't tell when a checking line is doing it's job very well??

Learn how to watch a hockey game before you spew stupid stuff that is senseless.

I agree with everyone else. He is doing his job. He drew a few penalties today. He's not going to be a big goal scorer, if that's what you're hoping for.

You should do a bit of research before spewing forth. A couple of tid bits for you:

1) Carcillo has a better +/- than Lappy AND Asham while playing the same amount of minutes as Asham per game and 3 less than lappy.

2) Lappy has scored 1 more point than Carcillo and Asham 2 more points than Carcillo.

While I do agree with the lament about wanting to see more in the way of offensive production, the guy is doing the job defensively and for the most part being in control of not taking stupid penalties, while being ANOTHER in the way of big agitator on the team.

P.S. God gift to hockey (aka Scottie Upshall) has two more points than Carcillo, is an even +/- player and has the same number of Pen minutes (except we know with Scottie, they are all the stupid minor penalty variety).

"P.S. God gift to hockey (aka Scottie Upshall) has two more points than Carcillo, is an even +/- player and has the same number of Pen minutes (except we know with Scottie, they are all the stupid minor penalty variety)."

Further to your point, Upshall was benched last Thursday for taking too many "reckless" penalties.

http://www.wopular.com/coyotes-upshall-works-controlling-emotions-energy

<<"Carcillo is a waste... He looked good against Carolina because they are trash.. Carcillo is very expendable... Bring some Phantoms up and move on...">>

He has been playing well all season and doing exactly what he has been asked to do and not getting called for very many penalties against. Not saying that there also isn't a Phantom, who can play a similar game but Carcillo, is certainly not a waste.

But fans like you who are biased against him will never 'see' this and bash him every chance you see fit.

No point in trying to explain the good things he has been doing to someone who doesn't understand the game enough.

pft.

carcillo was brought in billed as a third option offensive winger who would be a nasty, gritty tool in the flyers' goalscoring toolchest. he is super duper not any of that.

yeah, he's doing the job that's asked of him. which is to be a 4th line plumber who can kill some time while the actual hockey players on the team get a rest.

that's a job that needs to be done, so good on him. it's also a job that 70% of the AHL could do. a guy filling that role isn't a waste, but i am completely sympathetic to people who can't get the taste of the price paid for that guy out of their mouth. think what you will about upshall, but throw in the 2nd round pick...for a skill set that could have come off the UFA pile for league minimum. put it all in perspective, and i undersand how people see the carcillo situation as a whole as a waste.

and dude's GOT TO get rid of that molester-stache.

also, telling someone to learn how to watch a hockey game is about the most retarded thing ever. seriously.

Because he is doing everything he needs to do.

While he isn't showing up on the score sheet he is contributing.

He is drawing penalties, hitting, setting up goals with hustle, fighting smartly, and most importantly, not taking stupid penalties.