General Eagles discussion -  Gnats or Raiders? Which Eags are we?notify me whenever anyone posts in this discussionSubscribe  
 
From: mervmanva  Nov-1 7:14 pm 
To: ALL  (1 of 39) 
 105051.1 

I think a lot went in the Eags favor today...but I also think the Eags did dominate the gnats.

great showing today but Oakland is still firmly etched in my memory.

13-9 lost to Raiders means season's over boys....we're just fighting for draft status now.
 
   Options Reply 
  

 
From: thebirdman  Nov-1 7:19 pm 
To: mervmanva  (2 of 39) 
 105051.2 in reply to 105051.1 

its hard to get up for 8 preseason games. the raiders game was the fluke imo.

which giants are they is a good question too? the one that won in dallas and started 5-0, or the team that has been basically blown away in 3 straight.

"Thou shalt not speak ill of the Phillies, except those players that the cabal chooses as unworthy of support."

-author unknown (but presumed to be phanphil2009)



 
   Options Reply 
  

 
From: templegrad  Nov-1 7:21 pm 
To: mervmanva  (3 of 39) 
 105051.3 in reply to 105051.1 

Any Given Sunday, man.

I remember a year when we beat the 49ers 44-10. We looked like a SB team that day but didn't make the playoffs. The 49ers went on to win it all.

Let's just take it one game at a time.

 
   Options Reply 
  

 
From: mervmanva  Nov-1 7:22 pm 
To: thebirdman  (4 of 39) 
 105051.4 in reply to 105051.2 

good point...I was hoping this game would give a good showing of what this team really is...but I'm not sure we played one of the better teams in the NFC today.

Not knocking the win just really having a hard time gauging the team.

13-9 lost to Raiders means season's over boys....we're just fighting for draft status now.
 
   Options Reply 
  

 
From: thebirdman  Nov-1 7:26 pm 
To: mervmanva  (5 of 39) 
 105051.5 in reply to 105051.4 

cant gauge anybody except new orleans right now.

look at arizona, lost at home to SF and Carolina.

we have the same shot as everybody else as long as we show up each week for the season. i think home field is gonna be big in the nfc this year. im a falcons fan tomorrow night.

"Thou shalt not speak ill of the Phillies, except those players that the cabal chooses as unworthy of support."

-author unknown (but presumed to be phanphil2009)



 
   Options Reply 
  

 
From: bodybaggame  Nov-1 7:27 pm 
To: mervmanva  (6 of 39) 
 105051.6 in reply to 105051.4 

try to figure this out...gnats totally dominate the raiders...raiders beat the birds...birds totally dominate gnats...

u know the reason? one the raiders were up for the game after the gnats thumping...but AR lost the game with idiotic desire to stay with the pass...today was what should have happened to the raiders if we run the ball..

THIS IS FOR YOU PHILADELPHIA!
 
   Options Reply 
  

 
From: Bird_Seed  Nov-1 7:29 pm 
To: mervmanva  (7 of 39) 
 105051.7 in reply to 105051.1 

It's a good thing you're not a player Merv. Players need to have short memory. I believe we're more of what we showed today. Our o-line is getting better and so is Macnabb's rythm with the receivers.

November is here baby... and nobody plays better in november than the eagles.

The giants are are a fraud.

We donot negotiate with T.O.rists!
 
   Options Reply 
  

 
From: mervmanva  Nov-1 7:29 pm 
To: templegrad  (8 of 39) 
 105051.8 in reply to 105051.3 
glad thats worked in our favor more than not.
13-9 lost to Raiders means season's over boys....we're just fighting for draft status now.
 
   Options Reply 
  

 
From: mervmanva  Nov-1 7:31 pm 
To: thebirdman  (9 of 39) 
 105051.9 in reply to 105051.5 

<<<as long as we show up each week for the season.>>>

yeh...seems like every week we have the team to beat anyone or lose to anyone.

13-9 lost to Raiders means season's over boys....we're just fighting for draft status now.
 
   Options Reply 
  

 
From: mervmanva  Nov-1 7:32 pm 
To: bodybaggame  (10 of 39) 
 105051.10 in reply to 105051.6 
yeh that transitive theory never works out.
13-9 lost to Raiders means season's over boys....we're just fighting for draft status now.
 
   Options Reply 
  

 
From: mervmanva  Nov-1 7:34 pm 
To: Bird_Seed  (11 of 39) 
 105051.11 in reply to 105051.7 
problem is we seem to have a short memory after playing well too.
13-9 lost to Raiders means season's over boys....we're just fighting for draft status now.
 
   Options Reply 
  

 
From: LAPhilly1  Nov-1 7:35 pm 
To: mervmanva  (12 of 39) 
 105051.12 in reply to 105051.1 

looked good today, but I'm worried about the clock time. I mean maybe the birds are a team that only needs the ball for a short time to score. But I don't know if this D can't hammer teams.

As usual this D has a very hard time with the idea of 3 and out.

 
   Options Reply 
  

 
From: mervmanva  Nov-1 7:38 pm 
To: LAPhilly1  (13 of 39) 
 105051.13 in reply to 105051.12 

They ran rough shot over the gnats...long runs by Weaver and Shady??....hope you taped this game :-)

Eli was (as phildogs says) a double agent today...he was our secret weapon.

13-9 lost to Raiders means season's over boys....we're just fighting for draft status now.
 
   Options Reply 
  

 
From: Bird_Seed  Nov-1 7:39 pm 
To: mervmanva  (14 of 39) 
 105051.14 in reply to 105051.11 

Good point. However, you prepare differently for each opponent. The only memory I'd like to preserve is Andy Reid's so that he calls a balance game as he did today...

And if andy did that vs the raiders, you wouldn't have that sour taste in your mouth.

We donot negotiate with T.O.rists!
 
   Options Reply 
  

 
From: Illapa  Nov-1 7:42 pm 
To: mervmanva  (15 of 39) 
 105051.15 in reply to 105051.1 

Giaders.

We can stink out the joint totally.

We can look like one of the top very best in the league.

This has been true over the past 3 or 4 years years and has resulted in the ups and downs of the fans and the just over .500 record we have achieved in that time.

If we make the playoffs (which if today is evidence we are a lock, if the Raiders/Skins performances are the evidence, looks shaky) and can play consistently at our best, we could do it. But most of the real world evidence says no we will not. But even blind dogs find a bone every now and then. They can smell it and they do it. Let's see if the Birds play enough to smell it and elevate at prime time.

Frisbeetarianism is the belief that when you die, your soul goes up on the roof and gets stuck.

George Carlin



Edited 11/1/2009 7:43 pm ET by Illapa
 
   Options Reply 
  

 
From: thebirdman  Nov-1 8:01 pm 
To: Illapa  (16 of 39) 
 105051.16 in reply to 105051.15 

"But most of the real world evidence says no we will not. But even blind dogs find a bone every now and then. They can smell it and they do it. Let's see if the Birds play enough to smell it and elevate at prime time."

dont mean to take your post out of context but this was the part i found mosr pertinent.

my question to you is, what team has the real world evidence in the nfc?

every team except new orleans thus far has had a raiders-esque game.

"Thou shalt not speak ill of the Phillies, except those players that the cabal chooses as unworthy of support."

-author unknown (but presumed to be phanphil2009)



 
   Options Reply 
  

 
From: Illapa  Nov-1 9:13 pm 
To: thebirdman  (17 of 39) 
 105051.17 in reply to 105051.16 

We have had more than one. Every team has looked like a bad smelly turd against a team as bad as the Raiders?

If so, this league is worse than I expected and is on its way to being a NBA league.

To be perfectly honest, I do think that is what is happening.

Check the birds record over the past three years and most still have them at least in the top ten if not better.

Frisbeetarianism is the belief that when you die, your soul goes up on the roof and gets stuck.

George Carlin



Edited 11/1/2009 9:17 pm ET by Illapa
 
   Options Reply 
  

 
From: templegrad  Nov-1 11:23 pm 
To: mervmanva  (18 of 39) 
 105051.18 in reply to 105051.8 

Not sure what you mean here. We crushed zona last year - they beat us in the playoffs to go to the superbowl. We crushed the steelers - they won the superbowl. Things happen.

Now if recent history holds to form - the eagles will have a better second half record than first. If that happens this year we will win the division. I'm not afraid to go into minny or n'orleans with our "o".

I'm hoping for an Eagles-Saints NFC Championship game. We owe them a few.

 
   Options Reply 
  

 
From: sfofan  Nov-6 12:48 pm 
To: Illapa  (19 of 39) 
 105051.19 in reply to 105051.15 
Agreed, but in a weak NFC East and a weaker NFC in general they can make the playoffs. The Giants are fading. The Bears as well. We'll see how the Cowboys measure up but they aren't setting any records either. NO, Minn, maybe Arizona.. Atlanta ?? The Eagles don't have to run thru Denver, NE, Indy to get to the playoffs so there is hope. They are madly inconsistent as you so correctly point out but against consistently bad competition they might do ok.
 
   Options Reply 
  

 
From: Fmart322  Nov-6 1:03 pm 
To: thebirdman  (20 of 39) 
 105051.20 in reply to 105051.2 
The Giants team that won in Dallas had everything break their way that night. I'm not taking away from the Eagles win but the giants were way over rated. The Eagles are a good team, just like all the sports people said in the pre season. Most people picked the Eagles or Giants to win the division, conference or Super Bowl.
 
   Options Reply 
  

Navigate this discussion:  1-20 21-39
Rate My Interest:
   
Adjust text size:
Is this too complicated? Switch to Basic View

Back To Discussion List
Philly.com discussions are intended to be civil, friendly conversations. Please treat other participants with respect and in a way that you would want to be treated. You are responsible for what you say. And please, stay on topic.

These boards are monitored by Philly.com staff. We reserve the right at all times to remove any information or materials that are unlawful, threatening, abusive, libelous, defamatory, obscene, vulgar, pornographic, profane, indecent or otherwise objectionable to us in our sole discretion and to disclose any information necessary to satisfy the law, regulation, or government request. Personal attacks, especially on other board participants, are not permitted. We reserve the right to permanently block any user who violates these terms and conditions.

If you see an objectionable post, please report it to us using the "Report Violation" button.

© Copyright Philadelphia Media Holdings, LLC. All Rights Reserved. Any copying, redistribution or retransmission of any of the contents of this service without the expressed, written consent of Philadelphia Media Holdings, LLC, is prohibited.